Challenging Advanced Students

I am going to get up on my soapbox for a minute. ;)

I was looking at some blog posts and it led me to one where a teacher was very proud of how she challenges her high level readers. They read independently and then fill out a packet about the story they read. *sigh* Students who read above grade level deserve to learn new skills as well. The one way to make sure a child loses a passion for reading is to give them packets of work their classmates do not have to complete.

Do's and Don'ts for working with advanced students:

*Do differentiate classwork. Please don't simply give them more work to do. If they are finishing the classwork too quickly then it is not challenging enough for them. It's ok to give students different versions of the same activity and to have different expectations for them. In Kinder some students are still learning how to write their names and some can write a complete sentence. The paper I give them to write on looks very different. Spelling lists can be differentiated, homework. Is this extra work on your part-absolutely, but so worth it!

*  Do literature circles and book studies with them. Even if you just have one student, you can read a book with them during reading groups. It breaks my heart when I hear teachers say they don't meet with their high students for guided reading-every student deserves targeted instruction at that time.

* Peer tutoring does not mean students who finish their work help others. That is your job, not another student's. I've heard teachers say if you teach someone something, you learn it better. That is just not true. If a student can already read their sight words, helping a low student read their sight words is not helping them become better readers. They need focused instruction on fluency and comprehension strategies.

* When pairing your students for workstations, consider pairing high with high. If you pair a high and a low-the high student does the work and it's on a lower level than they need. I've seen this happen in many classrooms-a student who can read fluently is doing and activity to identify letters. Teachers justify this by saying low students just cannot work independently-you have to set those expectations just like you would for any other students. Give them tasks on their level. I have baskets with different animals on them (my students do not know they are grouped by level)-they can choose activities from their bin to work on with a partner.

* Have projects and independent studies that the students can work on when they finish their work. Let them choose what they want to learn more. You can print articles from Scholastic or other sources and let them create a project in any way they want to present the information. They can watch videos on Discovery Education or Brainpop and then synthesize that information into a a presentation. It can be an ongoing activity they are allowed to get out and work on when they are done with their independent work. And when they are done they can present it to the class. This is a much more exciting solution that "go read a book".

I don't want this to sound preachy, but I see students who are full of potential not grow the way they should because a teacher assumes they already know what they need to know, these students are not a concern. The "low" students get the attention, but in actuality ALL students deserve to have that attention. Everyone can better at a skill no matter how well they already do it!